New! Chocolate Brownie & Cookie Gifts | Fairytale Brownies

New Gifts for 2021!

Get your taste buds ready! This year, we're introducing our take on the classic Snickerdoodle cookie, our new seasonal bite-size Pumpkin Spice Magic Morsels, and a new Christmas gift design. Plus, our Candy Cane Crunch brownie is back for a limited time!

New Gifts for 2021!

Filters >
Sort By:
Arrow Down Arrow Up
Price (High to Low)
Price (Low to High)
Highest Rating
Piece Count (High to Low)
Piece Count (Low to High)
New Gifts Down Arrow Up Arrow
All Occasions
Get Well
Photo Gifts
Thank You
Thank You Healthcare
Thinking of You
Wedding Gifts
Contents Clear
Piece Count Clear
Price Clear
Gift Box Clear
Clear All Filters

The Fairytale Brownies Experience

It's our joy to work hard all year so we can make gifting more fun and magical for you! And we're not just saying that - introducing each year's brand-new chocolate gift baskets makes all our planning and preparation worth it.

As always, we're dedicated to creating premium food gifts that wow and amaze your recipients every time. Each brownie, cookie, and blondie is baked with Belgian dark chocolate, all-natural ingredients, and absolutely NO trans fats, preservatives, or artificial colors. No matter which gifts come and go throughout the years, our commitment to baking the best chocolate gifts in the world will never change.

Not sure where to start? For a classic chocolate gift, send one of our classically loved brownie gifts. For a mix of treat varieties, pick out a combo dessert gift that features a variety of cookies, brownies, and blondies. We promise you'll be pleased! Each gourmet gift is guaranteed fresh and delicious on arrival.

New Chocolate Gifts for 2021

This year, we're thrilled to announce a new cookie, two limited time seasonal flavors, and a gorgeous Christmas gift design.

Do you love cinnamon? We have the cookie for you. We've perfected the classic Snickerdoodle! With a soft, fluffy texture and a sweet sprinkling of cinnamon sugar, these cookies are a satisfying treat for any craving.

Pumpkin Spice is an autumn favorite we can't get enough of. Our new seasonal Pumpkin Spice Magic Morsels are a craveworthy blend of dark Belgian chocolate, creamy pumpkin, sweet cinnamon, warm nutmeg, and more.

Mint-lovers, rejoice! For a limited time, our Candy Cane Crunch brownie is back. This Belgian dark chocolate treat is infused with pure peppermint oil, drizzled with silky white chocolate, then topped with a festive layer of crunchy white and red sugar crystals. Each bite is bursting with winter enchantment.

Check out our new, Santa-approved Merry Christmas collection. Spreading cheer with a festive candy cane and peppermint themed band, it's gorgeous and gift-ready.

Browse popular categories like Happy Birthday gift baskets, prepare for October with a Halloween gift basket, or get started on your holiday shopping by taking a look at our Happy Holidays gift baskets and Christmas gift baskets.

Order now and ship later. You can choose any arrival date at checkout. We'll happily ship your gift fresh to anywhere in the world. Plus, enjoy free U.S. delivery - even to Alaska and Hawaii.

This website uses cookies. By using our services, you agree to our use of cookies.
Get Exclusive Offers
Need More Info?

Call us! We have all the answers (about brownies).


Need More Info?

Call us! We have all the answers
(about brownies).