Best-Selling Gifts: Brownies, Cookies, & More | Fairytale Brownies

Best-Selling Fairytale Gifts

These best-sellers have proven themselves time and time again as favorites! No matter the occasion, everyone can agree on irresistibly fudgy Belgian chocolate Fairytale Brownies.

Best-Selling Fairytale Gifts

Sort By:
Arrow Down Arrow Up
Price (High to Low)
Price (Low to High)
Highest Rating
Piece Count (High to Low)
Piece Count (Low to High)
Best-Sellers Down Arrow Up Arrow
All Occasions
Back to School
Get Well
Photo Gifts
Thank You
Thinking of You
Contents Clear
Piece Count Clear
Price Clear
Gift Box Clear
Clear All Filters

A Gift of Unparalleled Presentation & Taste

When you want to pull out all the stops for someone special, surprise them with a delicious gift basket of treats from Fairytale Brownies. From stunning presentation to the tantalizing fudgy and moist desserts inside, we can guarantee they'll be amazed and delighted every time!

For the loved ones who deserve only the best, we make it happen! We take pride in baking with:

  • All-natural and certified kosher ingredients
  • Rich Callebaut dark chocolate imported from Belgium
  • Real creamery butter, fluffy cake flour, and pure cane sugar
  • NO trans fats, preservatives, or artificial colors, ever!

Every day, our expert bakers carefully measure out ingredients, stir, and bake from scratch, then add toppings by hand. We're enthusiastic about delivering a premium, luxurious taste. We won't sacrifice our personal touch to do it! Fairytale Brownies aren't just the best brownie gifts out there - each one is a moment they'll remember forever!

The Finest Treats for Any Occasion

From small heartfelt gift favors to large party-pleasing giant boxes, we offer the best food gifts to fit any need! With 12 unique brownie flavors, six tasty types of cookie, and six irresistible varieties of blondie, there's a variety to fit any taste preference. Explore our full family of flavors!

From Thank You gifts to surprise Happy Birthday gift baskets, we have gorgeous themed bands to fit any occasion or holiday! We also have nut-free and sugar-free gifts to suit the food preferences or health needs of your recipients. Feel free to pick and choose your own flavors when you add an item to your cart.

Get Exclusive Offers
Need More Info?

Call us! We have all the answers (about brownies).


COVID-19 Updates  >
Need More Info?

Call us! We have all the answers
(about brownies).